A couple of weeks ago, I belatedly decided that it was time to catch up on my RSS reading–and try to stay caught up on my Web feeds instead of once again letting the unread-articles count ascend to four-digit altitudes.
After a couple of days of reacquainting myself with using various RSS apps to read the latest posts at my designated favorite sites, I had another overdue realization: Much as Winston Churchill said of democracy, RSS remains the worst way to keep up with what’s new on the Web, except for all the others.
“Really Simple Syndication,” a standard through which sites can automatically notify an RSS client about each new post, is old-in-Web-years and unfashionable. But it retains a few core advantages over its alleged replacements. One is control: my RSS feed only shows the sites I’ve added, not somebody else’s idea of what I should know. Another is what I’ll call a tolerance of time: A site that only posts an update a week is less likely to get lost when it occupies its own folder in the defined space of my RSS feed.
The third, maybe most important feature: Nobody owns RSS. When Google shut down Google Reader, I could export my subscriptions and move them to any other RSS host. I went with Feedly and have since been contentedly using that site’s free iOS and Android apps and the third-party Mac program ReadKit ($6.99 then, now $9.99).
I know many people now employ Twitter as their news feed, but I can’t make that work. I love Twitter as a social space, but in practice it’s been a miserable way to get the news. That’s not the fault of the service or its interface, but because it’s full of humans who often get excited about the same things that are really important to them in particular. The result: constant outbreaks of banter about inconsequential-to-normal-people developments like the addition of custom emoji to a chat-room app.
Twitter does help me learn about things happening outside of my usual reading habits, alerts me to breaking news hours faster than RSS and provides an incredibly useful way to talk to readers and hear from them. And yet the more I lean on Twitter as a communications channel, the worse it functions as a news mechanism.
(Facebook… oh, God, no. The News Feed filter I need there most would screen out all updates sharing outside content, so I’d only see things written, photographed or recorded by friends instead of an endless stream of links to content posted in the hope that it will go viral.)
Google Now’s cards for “Research topics,” “Stories to read,” and “New content available” can serve as an RSS substitute in some contexts. Unlike RSS, they’re not stuck with your last settings change and instead adjust to reflect where Google sees your attention wandering and where readers have clicked at the sites you visit. And unlike Twitter, these cards don’t get overrun with me-too content.
But relying on Google Now puts me further in Google’s embraces, and I think I give that company enough business already. (I’m quasi-dreading seeing cards about “RSS” and “Google Now” showing up in Google Now, based on my searches for this post.) It’s also a proprietary and closed system, unlike RSS.
I do appreciate Now as a tool to help me decide what sites deserve a spot in my RSS feed–and, by virtue of Feedly’s recent integration with Google Now, as a way to spotlight popular topics in my RSS that merit reading before others.
As I was going over this reevaluation of my info-grazing habits, I realized that I haven’t even gotten out of the habit of using bookmarks in my browsers. Yes, bookmarks! They remain a major part of my experience of Safari and the mobile version of Chrome–thought not, for whatever reason, the desktop edition.
Mine are embarrassingly untended, littered with lapsed memberships and defunct sites. But they also let me get to favorite sites by muscle memory and without excessive reliance on auto-complete (less helpful for going straight to a particular page on a site) and search (like I said, Google gets enough of my time already).
And my bookmarks would work better if there weren’t so many of them. I really should edit them today… right after I see if my signature file needs new ASCII art.
I used to use an RSS feed to capture my Twitter favorites. It was a sad day when Twitter killed that. Also, RSS feeds in DevonThink are really useful for capturing the rss items I want to keep for later.
I love RSS. It’s still the best way to keep up with my hometown newspaper, my favorite sports message board, my favorite political columnists, and yes, Rob’s posts on here and Yahoo Tech. I freaked out when Google Reader was shutting down until I found Feedly. And yeah, I’d love to get tweets via RSS– because we can’t, I end up paying very little attention to Twitter.
Pingback: :: Henrik Carlsson's Blog
Twitter and Facebook are fun, but RSS is the better source of news because it is persistent, not controlled by algorithms, and not subject to the vagaries of users.
Google Now’s suggestions are (for me) almost all click-bait articles with no real meaning. It’s just awful.
But I found this site through an article that popped up in my RSS feed. I actually have no complaints with RSS: it’s like someone emails updates on all my favorite sites. What’s not to like?
Discoverability? Great sites link to each other.
Efficiency? I can pop in, scan 40 web sites in a couple of minutes, and pop out in less than a minute (unless I really want to dig into an article).
Sure, content is king and I should no longer care about web sites, but we’re still years (a decade?) away from algorithms that genuinely distinguish quality articles and can’t be gamed by other algorithms.
Pingback: Did I do the whole vacation thing right? | Rob Pegoraro
Pingback: Weekly output: null | Rob Pegoraro
Pingback: Weekly output: credit-card fraud, SaaS developers, Amazon and Crystal City, digital marketing, CTO life, Roborace, For The Web, DMCA exemptions | Rob Pegoraro
Pingback: iPadOS 15 app-grid angst, cont’d. | Rob Pegoraro
Pingback: RSS lives, but not equally well on all of my devices | Rob Pegoraro