Call me crazy, but I’m warming to the smartwatch concept

From the thumbs-down I handed out to a Microsoft “SPOT Watch” in 2004 to last year’s “try again” dismissal of Samsung’s Galaxy Gear, I have not looked too favorably on the idea of wearing a smartwatch with a data stream of its own.

Android Wear watchBut now that I’m wearing yet another one of these devices, the Samsung Gear Live loaned to me at Google I/O, I find myself thinking of reasons why I’ll miss this thing when I have to send it back to Google PR.

Here’s the key thing it does right: provide a no-hands-required external display for my phone’s notifications list. If I’m cooking, gardening, biking or holding my daughter’s hand as we cross the street, I often have no ready way to get at the phone and so can only wonder if the beep or buzz of a notification is something I need to check or not.

Now I can see for myself. In some cases, I can dictate a reply by voice, but I’ve only done that once or twice; just knowing if what’s new on my phone is important enough to require taking it out of my pocket is good enough.

(I have, however, been surprised by how often I’ve leaned on Android Wear’s voice control while grilling: “OK Google, set a timer for five minutes.”)

Android Wear’s unavoidable updates are not always advantageous. As I noted in a Yahoo Tech column, I did not need or appreciate having the watch light up to alert me of a new e-mail (of course, spam) as I was putting our daughter to bed.

And that’s where Google could do a better job. Gmail has multiple ways to prioritize your e-mail–starring messages, marking conversations as important, displaying them in the “Primary” inbox tab–but none of them seem to inform what pops up on an Android Wear watch’s screen.

Should Apple surprise absolutely nobody by introducing an “iWatch” next month, I trust that such a timepiece will have an option to only notify you of new mail from people on your “VIP” list.

I also expect that any Apple smartwatch will be thinner than the Gear Live–which at roughly 3/8th of an inch thick, itself represents a welcome advance over the nearly half-inch thick Galaxy Gear and the 3/4-inch thick Microsoft-powered Suunto I hated in 2004.

That, in turn, should push the next Android Wear–or Pebble smartwatch, another promising contender–to get smarter and sleeker. And with these things costing $200 and change, that may be enough to get me to buy. And then you all can point and laugh at the nerd who decided he had to walk around with not one but two interactive gadgets.


12 thoughts on “Call me crazy, but I’m warming to the smartwatch concept

  1. I’ve used a Sony Smartwatch for about 6 months. Version 1 was about $80 when I bought it from Amazon. It does exactly what you say…displays callers and text messages a little more quickly than digging my phone out of my pocket. It has the added benefit of vibrating whenever I get a call or SMS, something which is helpful since I don’t always hear or feel my phone in loud environments. But it’s a little buggy–it doesn’t always connect to my Android phone as rapidly as I’d like, and I’ve never gotten the calendar reminder feature to work properly. For $80, though, it’s a steal.

  2. Pingback: Moto 360: A round smartwatch not yet ready to roll | VentureBeat | Reviews | by robpegoraro

  3. Pingback: Moto 360: A round smartwatch not yet ready to roll | Tech Auntie

  4. Pingback: Moto 360: A round smartwatch not yet ready to roll (review) | 381test

  5. Pingback: Moto 360: A round smartwatch not yet ready to roll (review) | DigitalCram

  6. Pingback: The fable of the one-handed phablet | Rob Pegoraro

  7. Pingback: CES 2015 travel-tech report: less battery angst, more about bandwidth | Rob Pegoraro

  8. Pingback: The One Feature that Will Determine the Quality of the Apple Watch | Dashing

  9. Pingback: Smartwatch withdrawal | Rob Pegoraro

  10. Pingback:’s first smartwatch winds down | Smartwatch

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.