Reader reports on AT&T data throttling

Since my USA Today column covered AT&T’s recent habit of throttling back the connections of unlimited-data subscribers judged to be in the top 5 percent of users in a given market, I’ve been hearing from readers subjected to this penalty. To judge from their input, you really don’t want to be among the 5 percent at that carrier.

Of the five people to report getting AT&T’s warning and then having their connection throttled, all said their downloads downshifted to 100 to 150 kilobits per second. (A sixth didn’t specify a number but also said the slowdown came without a warning.) That’s about the speed of AT&T’s decade-old GPRS data service, which was barely adequate for the WAP browsers of 2002.

The screenshots at right, showing the warning sent via text message and a post-throttling bandwidth test, come from Kevin Reifel of Williamstown, N.J.

Two of these readers cited monthly bandwidth usage above 5 gigabytes, fueled by the fast LTE service on their new Samsung Galaxy S II Skyrocket phones. Three iPhone users, however, reported bandwidth use below or barely above the 3-GB quota of AT&T’s current $30/month option.

Dave Spenik, of Walnut, Calif., said he also received warnings for hitting just 2.1 GB and change but avoided throttling those months–matching one of the first reports I got about this issue.

There was no real pattern to the locations of these reports, aside from them coming from outer suburbs of various metro areas (Washington, Philadelphia and Los Angeles).

But–you knew this was coming–these customers do share a pronounced unhappiness with AT&T. Gaithersburg, Md., resident David Rothfeld declared: “I will never go back to ATT again.” Wrote Spenik: “I plan to lodge complaints with the FCC, Calif State Attorney General, and Calif Public Utilities Commission, and am going to begin preparation to sue in Calif Small Claims Court.” Reifel: “I would have more respect for ATT if they simply just advised all their current unlimited data users that the plan was going away and to please pick a new plan.”

(The company did that in 2010 when it terminated an unlimited plan for users of some data-only devices.)

It’s true that most users don’t come near 2 gigs a month. The Samsung Galaxy Nexus that I’ve been testing extensively shows only 866 megabytes used over the last three weeks, nowhere near Verizon’s monthly 2 GB quota. But at least that’s an obvious limit. I would not be comfortable worrying that crossing an undefined and changing threshold would get my smartphone kneecapped through the rest of the billing cycle.

6 thoughts on “Reader reports on AT&T data throttling

  1. The issue with this throttling the unlimited plan is the email they send the 2nd paragraph says “As mentioned on a previous bill, we’re also taking additional, more immediate steps to help address network congestion and improve reliability. One of these steps involves a change for some customers who use extraordinarily large amounts of data in a single billing period – about 12 times more data than the average smartphone user. ” I keep going back to network congestion, really network congestion. So being on an unlimited plan throttling us at 2gb will reduce network congestion but if we spent $30 for 3gb or $50 for 5gb our usage wouldn’t cause network congestion. How is that? AT&T needs to wake up 2g is not extraordinarily large amount of data.

  2. I agree . 2gb is not alot in this day in age where a new YouTube goody-bag laugh or even the fact netflix and Hulu are now approved apps for watching or catching up on your tv shows. It’s time for AT&T to get with the times. My higher data usages are actually during the middle of the night and during a time when most users aren’t using their phones. I also live in an area that is not a predominant market for at&t. We need to either band together in a class action lawsuit or start telling everyone to use more data. It’s a complete scam because the only way to stop the throttling is to switch to their more expensive capped data plan.

    • What can we do about this? I also have the original unlimited plan. They are going to start charging me an extra $5/mo.

  3. Pingback: Weekly output: AT&T throttling, car audio, Wikipedia, typewriters, 3G dead zones | Rob Pegoraro

  4. Pingback: The Best Wireless Carriers | INNOVATIVE HOME

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.